top of page

WWFC Application Information Hub
Planning application PL/26/07779/FA

13. Noise and lighting

What happens to the character of the site after dark?

This section can be fairly short, because the Applicant's technical assessments do not presently show a major residential noise or light-spill problem.

That should be acknowledged.

The more interesting issue is whether those assessments fully capture the change from a relatively quiet, low-brightness golf-course landscape to an intensively used professional sports complex operating into the evening.

​

Noise: the residential assessment is relatively reassuring

The Environmental Statement concludes that operational noise from the sports pitches and padel courts would generally have Minor Adverse to Negligible (Not Significant) effects at nearby residential properties. Changes in road-traffic noise are assessed as Negligible.

SPTF therefore does not suggest that the submitted noise assessment demonstrates a major residential noise problem.

But residential façades are not the only places where people experience the site.

The existing public routes cross a generally quiet golf-course landscape. The proposed diverted and permissive routes would bring walkers much closer to a professional football environment, with the ordinary sounds of training and matches — voices, coaching instructions, whistles, ball impacts, vehicle activity and spectators.

​

That change is relevant to recreational amenity, even where it does not amount to unacceptable statutory noise at nearby houses.

​

“Not significant” at the nearest house does not necessarily mean “no change” for somebody walking beside the training ground.

​

Lighting: controlling spill is not the same as preserving darkness

The Applicant's lighting assessment concludes that the proposed installation can comply with the relevant limits for an E2 low-district-brightness environment, subject to the proposed aiming, shielding and switching arrangements.

Again, that is important evidence and should not be ignored.

​

But it answers a particular question: how much unwanted light reaches surrounding receptors?

​

It does not fully answer a different question:

What is the visual effect of introducing illuminated professional football pitches, lighting columns and evening activity into a landscape which is currently comparatively dark?

​

The Landscape and Visual Impact Assessment itself says that lighting was not considered further because the effects would be “contained within the Site”.

​

That reasoning deserves scrutiny because walkers and other recreational users can be inside the Site.

​​

Lighting also matters for wildlife

Artificial lighting is not only a question of what nearby residents can see.

The Applicant's own ecological assessment identifies bats and invertebrates as species requiring particular consideration in relation to lighting. It says floodlighting has been concentrated towards the centre of the developed areas in order to maintain buffers with boundary woodland.

That mitigation is important because the golf course contains mature trees, woodland and connected habitats used by at least nine bat species.

​

The detailed mitigation strategy for bats and invertebrates is, however, still to be secured by planning condition rather than fully defined at this stage.

​

Keeping light away from nearby houses is not the only test. Dark habitat corridors and woodland edges also need to remain genuinely dark enough to perform their ecological function.​

​

Operating hours matter

The Transport Assessment says that the Academy is expected to operate from 08:00 to 21:00 on weekdays and 08:00 to 17:00 at weekends, with some support activity outside those hours.

​

The lighting design allows individual pitches to be separately switched and dimmed, and specific operating hours could be controlled by planning condition.

​

That is useful mitigation — but only if the actual permitted hours and lighting controls are clearly secured.

​

The key distinction

The Council therefore needs to consider two different questions:

  • Does noise or light exceed technical limits at nearby homes?

  • How much does evening operation alter the character and recreational experience of the site itself?

​​

The first question appears relatively well addressed by the Applicant's technical assessments.

The second deserves more attention.

Containing light within the site does not mean that the site itself remains dark.

Support our campaign
Stoke Poges Task Force is funded by supporters. Contributions help us meet the costs of printing, communications, professional advice and, if necessary, legal action.

Stoke Poges Task Force Ltd
Sort Code 04-06-05
Account 30833427
Reference: "Contribution"

The Stoke Poges Task Force

Contact: info@greenspacetaskforce.org

Postal: c/o Stoke Poges Village Social Club

             Village Centre, Rogers Lane

             Stoke Poges, SL2 4LP

follow us on facebook

  • Facebook
bottom of page