WWFC Application Information Hub
Planning application PL/26/07779/FA
10. Trees, ecology and landscape
What would be removed, replaced and changed?
The Performance Hub would transform a substantial part of the existing golf-course landscape.
That change is not confined to new buildings and pitches. It involves extensive tree removal, earthworks, new planting and habitat creation, followed by a long period during which the replacement landscape would have to establish.
The tree loss is much greater than the headline figure
The Planning Statement refers to the loss of 203 trees.
The Applicant's Arboricultural Impact Assessment gives a fuller picture: 204 individually recorded trees, 18 complete tree groups and parts of a further 3 groups are proposed for removal.
Those groups contain many individual trees. Using the Applicant's own group counts, SPTF estimates the physical loss at approximately 408 individual trees.
Almost all of that loss is associated with the Performance Hub. The assessment identifies only one tree removal at Farnham Park and none as necessary for the 12-hole golf-course reconfiguration.
Mature trees are being exchanged for young planting
The application places considerable emphasis on planting more than 2,400 new trees.
Much of that planting, however, consists of young woodland whips around 80–100 cm high, while existing trees proposed for removal include established specimens 15–20 metres high with substantial crowns and decades of remaining life.
Young woodland planting may ultimately become valuable habitat.
But it does not immediately replace mature canopy, shade, deadwood, habitat complexity or the established parkland character of the site.
The loss happens immediately. The replacement takes years or decades.
What does the biodiversity calculation actually show?
Biodiversity Net Gain is measured in Habitat Units.
Different habitats — grassland, trees, woodland, scrub, ponds and others — are assigned values according to factors including their extent, distinctiveness and condition. Development can cause Habitat Units to be lost, while new or improved habitats can create additional units.
For this development, a minimum 10% Biodiversity Net Gain is mandatory. The application claims an overall gain of 13.96%, a mere 4% above the absolute minimum.
The table below shows something more useful than the percentage alone: which habitats are actually being lost, and which habitats are intended to replace them.
Some habitat categories contain more than one entry in the statutory metric. Where a time-to-target figure is shown above, it represents the longer relevant creation period within that category.
The numbers tell an interesting story
The development removes 87.61 Habitat Units and proposes 112.09 units of newly created habitat. That gives a gross creation-minus-loss difference of 24.48 units. Further gains are claimed through enhancement of habitats which remain on the site, bringing the Applicant's total predicted increase to 43.57 Habitat Units — 13.96% above the existing baseline. This is almost exactly the amount gained through newly created Other Neutral Grassland (43.89 HU)
Perhaps surprisingly, the largest loss in the metric is not trees.
Modified grassland accounts for 55.18 Habitat Units of loss, much of it associated with the existing golf-course landscape. The loss attributed to Rural Trees is 29.86 units.
That does not mean that the grass is somehow “more important” than the trees.
It illustrates what the biodiversity metric measures. A large area of relatively ordinary habitat can accumulate a substantial number of Habitat Units simply because of its extent. The metric is designed to measure biodiversity value, not how strongly individual landscape features contribute to the character or enjoyment of a place.
2,460 new trees — but only 0.76 additional tree units
The same table puts the headline replacement-tree number into perspective.
The application proposes 2,460 new Rural Trees, which are credited with 30.62 Habitat Units. But approximately 29.86 Rural Tree units are being lost.
The resulting increase in this category is therefore only:
30.62 − 29.86 = 0.76 Habitat Units
The 2,460 trees are important, but most of their calculated value is needed simply to replace the tree habitat value being removed.
By contrast, a major part of the gain comes from changing the amount and type of grassland, particularly the creation of Other Neutral Grassland.
The calculation does recognise that new habitat takes time
There is another important detail.
The statutory metric does not pretend that newly planted habitat has its full future value immediately. It applies a temporal discount according to the time expected for the habitat to reach its target condition.
The proposed Other Neutral Grassland is generally assumed to reach its target condition in about 5 years. New Rural Trees are assigned a time to target of up to 27 years.
The Habitat Units shown in the table already reflect that delay.
That is important — but it does not remove the need for effective monitoring.
The temporal discount accounts for delay. It does not guarantee success.
The calculation still assumes that the grassland will establish, that the trees will survive, that the required management will take place and that the habitats will actually reach their target conditions.
If those assumptions are not achieved, the future Habitat Units on which the claimed 13.96% BNG depends are not fully delivered.
The margin above the statutory minimum is only 3.96 percentage points. In Habitat Unit terms, there is only about 12.36 HU of headroom. The scheme therefore depends on the great majority of its proposed habitat creation and enhancement being successfully delivered.
That is why establishment, monitoring, replacement of failures and enforceable long-term management matter.
Habitat for wildlife is not the whole landscape
There is one further distinction which is especially important here.
Habitat Units measure biodiversity. They do not measure the quality of the landscape experienced by people.
Hundreds of mature trees can therefore account for fewer Habitat Units than a large area of grassland, while having a profound effect on the appearance and character of the site.
Mature trees provide scale, structure, shade, seasonal change, framed views and much of the established parkland character through which golfers and walkers currently move. Removing them changes that experience even if a biodiversity spreadsheet ultimately records a numerical net gain.
Those effects are assessed separately through landscape and visual impact, arboricultural impact and recreational amenity.
The Applicant's own landscape assessment acknowledges significant adverse effects during the period in which the replacement landscape establishes, with adverse effects still remaining at Year 15.
So the headline should not simply be: 13.96% Biodiversity Net Gain.
A more complete description is: The development predicts a 13.96% increase in biodiversity value under the statutory metric, while at the same time removing substantial existing habitat and transforming a mature recreational landscape.
We already have a local test of whether ecological promises are delivered
This site already has an ecological management scheme requiring habitat creation, establishment, monitoring and long-term management, as compensation for habitat loss and development of two padel courts on the site.
Buckinghamshire Council itself was (and still is) in large parts responsible for the successful execution of this ecological management plan.
The present application acknowledges that earlier ecological enhancements “have not yet been realised”.
SPTF's own field inspection also indicates that establishment of the previous tree planting is seriously deficient, while Japanese knotweed which was already subject to an eradication programme remains thriving on the site in 2026.
None of this proves that the new scheme will fail.
But it does provide a very good reason not simply to assume that planting shown on a plan will become the habitat predicted by a biodiversity calculation.
The larger the future benefit relied upon, the stronger the arrangements for establishment, monitoring, replacement and enforcement need to be.
Biodiversity gain does not mean landscape harm disappears
The Applicant's own Landscape and Visual Impact Assessment predicts Moderate Adverse (Significant) landscape effects during the short and medium term.
Even at Year 15, residual adverse landscape effects remain.
That is important because new planting may eventually screen much of the development — but:
Screening a development is not the same as preserving the landscape it replaced.
The existing experience is of an open, mature golf-course landscape structured by fairways, individual mature trees and woodland groups.
The proposed experience is of a secure professional football complex, progressively screened by new planting.
Biodiversity value and landscape value are not the same thing.
What should the Council ask?
The central questions are:
-
whether the future habitats on which the claimed BNG depends are realistically deliverable within the assumed timescales;
-
how establishment, monitoring and replacement of failures will be secured and enforced over the lifetime of the development
-
whether the loss of mature trees and existing landscape character has been given appropriate weight separately from the BNG calculation; and
-
whether the predicted ecological and landscape benefits will remain secured for long enough to make them real.
